Summary of September 2026 Labor Law Updates for Indianapolis, Indiana
September 2026 brought several important developments in Indiana labor and employment law, including court decisions addressing workers’ compensation, employment contracts, unemployment benefits, and disability discrimination. This monthly roundup from HKM Employment Attorneys highlights significant rulings and enforcement actions affecting Indiana employees, employers, HR professionals, and compliance leaders.
At-a-Glance Overview
The following developments were decided or announced in September 2026:
-
Harrison County Parks & Recreation v. Hussung: Indiana appeals court upholds workers’ compensation benefits for an employee injured in a vehicle accident following a fainting episode.
-
Miskulin v. Otolaryngology Associates, LLC: Court rejects a physician’s claim that another medical practice unlawfully interfered with her employment contract.
-
J.S. and K.J. v. Review Board: Appeals court upholds the denial of unemployment overpayment waivers involving pandemic-era benefits.
-
J.E. v. Review Board: Court upholds the denial of unemployment benefits following an employee’s discharge for refusing workplace instructions.
-
EEOC v. Damar Services, Inc.: Indianapolis employer agrees to pay $65,000 to resolve allegations of disability discrimination against a deaf job applicant.
If you have questions about your rights at work, believe you have experienced employment discrimination, or need assistance with an employment-related dispute, contact HKM Employment Attorneys. Our attorneys help employees throughout Indiana understand their legal options and pursue remedies when their workplace rights have been violated.
Harrison County Parks & Recreation v. Hussung — Workers’ Compensation Ruling
Date: September 4, 2026
Case Number: 26A-EX-00780
Summary:
The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed a workers’ compensation award for David Hussung, an employee of Harrison County Parks & Recreation who suffered serious injuries in a vehicle accident while performing a work-related errand.
Hussung was driving a county vehicle to purchase supplies for a playground project when he briefly lost consciousness. His vehicle left the highway and crashed, causing fractures to his vertebrae and sternum.
The employer challenged the workers’ compensation award, arguing that Hussung’s fainting episode resulted from a personal medical condition rather than a workplace hazard.
The Court of Appeals disagreed. Although the loss of consciousness was unrelated to Hussung’s employment, his job responsibilities required him to operate a vehicle at highway speeds. Those circumstances increased the danger associated with his fainting episode and contributed directly to the severity of his injuries.
The court affirmed the Indiana Worker’s Compensation Board’s decision and ordered a 5% increase in the employee’s compensation award under Indiana Code § 22-3-4-8(f).
Implications:
This ruling reinforces an important principle of Indiana workers’ compensation law: an injury may qualify for benefits even when an underlying medical event is unrelated to employment.
Employees who suffer injuries following fainting episodes, seizures, or other personal medical events may still qualify for compensation when their work duties increase the resulting danger.
For Indiana employers, the decision highlights the importance of evaluating the circumstances surrounding workplace accidents rather than focusing exclusively on the underlying medical cause.
Miskulin v. Otolaryngology Associates, LLC — Employment Contract and Tortious Interference Ruling
Date: September 23, 2026
Case Number: 25A-PL-02078
Summary:
The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment in favor of Otolaryngology Associates, LLC, in a dispute involving a physician’s employment contract with Community Health Network.
Dr. Judiann Miskulin worked as an endocrine surgeon for Community Health Network under an employment agreement that automatically renewed and allowed either party to terminate the relationship with 180 days’ written notice.
After Community Health Network terminated her agreement in 2023, Miskulin sued Otolaryngology Associates, a separate medical practice that provided physician services to the network.
Miskulin alleged that the practice had undermined her professional relationships and interfered with her ability to perform her duties, ultimately contributing to the termination of her employment.
The trial court granted summary judgment to Otolaryngology Associates. The Court of Appeals affirmed, concluding that the lower court had not erred in rejecting her tortious interference claim.
The appellate court also determined that Miskulin had waived a challenge to an affidavit submitted during the proceedings because she had not properly objected to it before the trial court.
Implications:
The decision illustrates the evidentiary challenges involved in pursuing claims for tortious interference with employment contracts under Indiana law.
Employees who believe that a third party improperly caused their termination generally must establish more than workplace disagreements, professional competition, or strained relationships.
For physicians, executives, and other professionals working under employment agreements, the case emphasizes the importance of contractual termination provisions and evidence establishing actionable interference by an outside party.
The decision also demonstrates why properly preserving objections during litigation is essential to protecting appellate rights.
J.S. and K.J. v. Review Board of the Indiana Department of Workforce Development — Unemployment Benefits Ruling
Date: September 4, 2026
Case Number: 26A-EX-00018
Summary:
The Indiana Court of Appeals upheld decisions requiring two unemployment claimants to repay benefits they had improperly received during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The claimants, identified as K.J. and J.S., received combinations of state and federally funded unemployment assistance. After reviewing their claims, the Indiana Department of Workforce Development determined that certain payments were improper because the claimants had not accurately reported employment earnings.
Both individuals sought waivers that would relieve them of their repayment obligations.
The Department denied their requests, finding that neither claimant satisfied the requirement of being without fault in creating the overpayment. Administrative law judges upheld those determinations, and the Unemployment Insurance Review Board affirmed.
On appeal, the claimants challenged the standards applied to determine fault and raised additional arguments concerning notification deadlines and procedural fairness.
The Court of Appeals affirmed the Review Board’s decisions, leaving the repayment obligations in place.
The ruling was issued as a memorandum decision, meaning it does not establish binding precedent but may be cited for persuasive purposes under Indiana appellate rules.
Implications:
This decision highlights the continuing legal consequences of unemployment benefit payments made during the COVID-19 pandemic.
For Indiana workers, the ruling emphasizes that receiving unemployment benefits does not necessarily establish permanent entitlement to those payments. Claimants may face repayment obligations if subsequent reviews identify inaccurate or incomplete earnings information.
Workers seeking an overpayment waiver should understand that eligibility may depend on whether they were at fault in receiving the excess benefits, along with other applicable statutory requirements.
The case also illustrates the importance of maintaining accurate employment and earnings records when applying for state or federal unemployment assistance.
J.E. v. Review Board of the Indiana Department of Workforce Development — Unemployment Eligibility and Employee Misconduct Ruling
Date: September 1, 2026
Case Number: 26A-EX-00712
Summary:
The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed the denial of unemployment benefits to a former automotive repair shop employee who was discharged after failing to follow workplace instructions.
The employee, identified as J.E., worked at a tire and automotive repair business, where his duties included preparing repair estimates, communicating with customers, and accepting vehicles for service.
According to the Review Board’s findings, J.E. accepted a vehicle for repairs despite instructions from a mechanic and the business owner not to do so. He subsequently failed to ensure that the vehicle was removed from the business premises as directed.
The employer terminated J.E.’s employment for failing to follow repeated instructions.
The Indiana Department of Workforce Development determined that the discharge was for just cause under Indiana Code § 22-4-15-1(d)(5), which addresses refusal to obey instructions.
J.E. challenged that determination, arguing that his conduct did not satisfy the required standard for disqualifying misconduct.
The Court of Appeals affirmed the denial of benefits. The court concluded that J.E. had failed to provide an adequate appellate record and had substantially failed to comply with procedural requirements. It also determined that the Review Board’s unchallenged findings supported its conclusion that the discharge was for just cause.
The decision was issued as a nonprecedential memorandum decision.
Implications:
The ruling highlights the distinction between termination from employment and eligibility for unemployment benefits.
Although an employer may have grounds to terminate an employee, unemployment eligibility requires a separate analysis under Indiana law.
In this case, the employee’s repeated failure to follow workplace instructions supported the finding of discharge for just cause.
For Indiana employees, the decision reinforces the importance of understanding workplace expectations and documenting circumstances involving disputed instructions or disciplinary actions.
For employers, it demonstrates the value of maintaining clear records of workplace directives, employee conduct, and the reasons for termination.
The decision also underscores the importance of following procedural requirements when appealing an adverse unemployment determination.
EEOC v. Damar Services, Inc. — Disability Discrimination Settlement
Date: September 2, 2026
Case Number: 1:26-cv-00575-MPB-TAB
Summary:
The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission announced a $65,000 settlement with Damar Services, Inc., an Indianapolis-based residential services provider for individuals with developmental disabilities.
The settlement resolved a federal lawsuit alleging violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) during the company’s hiring process.
According to the EEOC, Damar Services rejected a qualified applicant for a housekeeping position because he was deaf, despite his ability to perform the essential functions of the position with or without reasonable accommodation.
The agency alleged that the company conducted a telephone interview in March 2023, learned that the applicant was deaf, and subsequently informed him that it could not accommodate his disability.
The EEOC also alleged that Damar maintained hiring standards requiring applicants to communicate verbally and possess hearing and vision within normal ranges. The agency contended that these standards improperly screened out applicants with disabilities and that the company’s interview process included prohibited disability-related medical inquiries.
Under the two-year consent decree, Damar agreed to pay $65,000 in monetary relief and implement additional measures, including:
-
Revising job postings and qualification standards involving hearing and vision requirements.
-
Engaging a vocational rehabilitation specialist to evaluate workplace facilities, policies, and hiring standards.
-
Providing disability discrimination training to employees.
-
Posting notices explaining employee protections against disability discrimination.
-
Submitting compliance reports to the EEOC.
The settlement resolved the litigation without a judicial finding that the company violated the ADA.
Implications:
This settlement illustrates the protections available to Indiana job applicants under federal disability discrimination law.
The ADA generally prohibits covered employers from using qualification standards that screen out individuals with disabilities unless the standards are job-related and consistent with business necessity.
Employers must also evaluate whether qualified applicants can perform essential job functions with reasonable accommodations, rather than automatically excluding applicants because of hearing, vision, or other disabilities.
For Indiana employers, the settlement reinforces the importance of reviewing job descriptions, interview procedures, and accommodation policies to ensure compliance with federal requirements.
For workers and job applicants with disabilities, it demonstrates that discriminatory hiring practices may give rise to legal remedies even when an employment relationship never begins.
Key Takeaways for Indiana Employees and Employers
The September 2026 employment update highlights several important themes affecting Indiana workplace rights.
First, the workers’ compensation ruling in Harrison County Parks & Recreation v. Hussung demonstrates that an employee may qualify for benefits when workplace conditions increase the severity of injuries caused by a personal medical event.
Second, the decision in Miskulin v. Otolaryngology Associates illustrates the challenges of proving unlawful third-party interference with an employment agreement, particularly when the contract expressly permits termination with notice.
Third, the unemployment decisions reinforce the importance of accurately reporting earnings, following reasonable workplace instructions, and understanding the procedural requirements governing unemployment appeals.
Finally, the EEOC’s settlement with Damar Services demonstrates the continuing importance of disability accommodations and nondiscriminatory hiring practices.
Together, these developments underscore the importance of understanding employment contracts, maintaining accurate documentation, and protecting employee rights under Indiana and federal law.
Conclusion: Looking Back on Indiana’s Labor Law Updates from September 2026
As Indiana courts continue to shape employee protections around discrimination, FMLA, wrongful termination, separation agreements, wage disputes, ADA accommodations, non-competes, and hostile work environments, having local counsel matters. At HKM Employment Attorneys in Indianapolis, our fearless litigators—including Katie Bensberg, Natalie Dickey, and Benjamin Ellis—focus solely on representing employees in claims ranging from contract breaches and unpaid wages to whistleblower retaliation and employer investigations. With responsive client care and deep familiarity with both local and federal labor law, we stand ready to guide you. If recent case outcomes reflect your experience, contact our Indianapolis office to see how we can help protect your rights in state or federal court.