Summary of August 2026 Labor Law Updates for Indianapolis, Indiana
August 2026 brought several notable developments in Indiana labor and employment law, including decisions involving workplace discrimination, employer liability for employee misconduct, wage-and-hour claims, collective bargaining, and union activity. This roundup from HKM Employment Attorneys highlights developments relevant to Indiana employees, employers, HR professionals, and compliance leaders.
Employees and employers with questions about Indiana workplace rights or an employment dispute can contact HKM Employment Attorneys at hkm.com to discuss their legal options.
J.M. v. Catucky Derby, Inc. — Indiana Court of Appeals Ruling
Date: August 10, 2026
Case No.: 26A-CT-122
Summary:
The Indiana Court of Appeals reversed the dismissal of negligence and vicarious-liability claims brought by an employee against Catucky Derby, Inc., a delivery contractor. The plaintiff alleged that another employee sexually assaulted and raped her while both employees were on a work assignment in St. Louis and staying in housing arranged or controlled by their employer.
The plaintiff alleged, among other things, that the employer failed to supervise the coworker, failed to protect or warn her, negligently hired and retained him, and failed to establish adequate safeguards. She also alleged that the coworker was acting within the scope of his employment.
The Court of Appeals held that the allegations were sufficient at the pleading stage to support the direct-negligence claims. It also concluded that whether the coworker’s conduct fell within the scope of employment presented factual questions that were not appropriately resolved through a motion to dismiss. The case was reversed and remanded for further proceedings.
Implications:
The decision is important for Indiana workplace rights because it illustrates that an employer’s potential liability for coworker misconduct may extend beyond traditional harassment or discrimination claims. When alleged misconduct occurs during employer-arranged travel or at employer-controlled lodging, questions about supervision, control, and the scope of employment may require factual development before a case can be dismissed.
International Union of Painters and Allied Trades District Council No. 91 v. Hall Aluminum Products — Federal Court Ruling
Date: August 13, 2026
Case No.: 1:26-cv-00120-ALT
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Indiana dismissed, with permission to amend, a union’s lawsuit seeking to compel Hall Aluminum Products to arbitrate a wage grievance.
Hall and the union had previously been parties to a collective bargaining agreement that expired in June 2021. In late 2025, the union raised a dispute over wages being paid on an Indianapolis project and filed a grievance in January 2026. Hall declined to arbitrate, arguing that the agreement containing the arbitration provision had expired.
The court concluded that the union’s complaint did not plausibly allege that the contractual obligation to arbitrate remained in effect. It noted that although employers generally must maintain certain terms and conditions of employment after a CBA expires while negotiations continue, that obligation does not automatically extend an expired contractual arbitration provision. The court nevertheless gave the union an opportunity to amend its complaint.
Implications:
For unionized Indiana workplaces, the ruling highlights an important distinction between maintaining the status quo after a collective bargaining agreement expires and continuing contractual dispute-resolution obligations. Employers and unions should pay close attention to whether arbitration provisions expressly survive expiration and whether a later grievance concerns rights that accrued under the expired agreement.
Rhodes v. Hopp, Inc. d/b/a Night Moves — Wage-and-Hour Settlement
Date: August 14, 2026
Case No.: 1:25-cv-00068-JPH-MG
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana granted final approval to a $220,000 settlement resolving wage claims brought against Hopp, Inc., which operates Night Moves in Bloomington.
The plaintiff alleged that exotic dancers had been classified as independent contractors and had not received wages directly from the business, in violation of the federal Fair Labor Standards Act and the Indiana Wage Payment Statute. The settlement covered an FLSA collective with 37 participants and an Indiana wage-law class containing 174 members.
The court determined that the settlement represented a fair and reasonable resolution of the wage dispute and granted final approval. The settlement fund also included attorneys’ fees, litigation expenses, and a service award for the named plaintiff.
Implications:
The settlement underscores the continuing significance of worker-classification issues under both federal and Indiana labor law. Businesses that classify workers as independent contractors can face substantial exposure when the realities of the working relationship support employee status, particularly when minimum-wage or overtime obligations are involved.
Southern Aluminum Finishing Company, Inc. — NLRB Order
Date: August 17, 2026
Case Nos.: 25-CA-325283 and 25-CA-325296
Summary:
The National Labor Relations Board adopted an administrative law judge’s findings that Southern Aluminum Finishing Company committed unfair labor practices at its Indianapolis operation. No party filed exceptions to the administrative law judge’s June decision, so the NLRB adopted the findings, conclusions, and recommended order.
The underlying decision involved an employee who was also organizing for Sheet Metal Workers Local 20. The administrative law judge found that the company unlawfully suspended and discharged the employee because of protected union activity. The decision also found problems with confidentiality and nonsolicitation provisions that restricted employees’ rights under the National Labor Relations Act.
The recommended remedies included reinstatement, compensation for lost earnings and certain related expenses, removal of references to the unlawful discipline and discharge, rescission of unlawful policies, and workplace notice requirements.
Implications:
The Board’s August action made the administrative law judge’s order the NLRB’s order in the case. Indiana employers should remember that employees generally have federally protected rights to organize, discuss workplace conditions, and engage in other concerted activity, and workplace policies cannot unlawfully interfere with those rights.
Highbaugh v. Exelead, Inc. — Seventh Circuit Employment Discrimination Ruling
Date: August 24, 2026
Case No.: 25-2638
Summary:
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit affirmed summary judgment for Indianapolis-based Exelead, Inc. in a failure-to-promote lawsuit alleging race and age discrimination.
Richard Highbaugh, a Black employee who was 60 at the time, had worked for Exelead for nearly three decades. He sought a Materials Manager position that ultimately went to a white candidate in his thirties. Highbaugh alleged that the decision violated Title VII, Section 1981, and the Age Discrimination in Employment Act.
Exelead maintained that the selected applicant had the type of larger-scale management experience the hiring manager wanted. The Seventh Circuit concluded that Highbaugh had not produced evidence from which a reasonable jury could find that explanation was a pretext for discrimination. The court also explained that providing additional, consistent details about an employment decision does not necessarily amount to the kind of shifting explanation that can support a finding of pretext.
Implications:
The ruling provides useful guidance for Indiana employers and employees litigating discrimination claims involving promotions. An employee challenging a hiring or promotion decision generally must do more than disagree with an employer’s assessment of qualifications; evidence must support an inference that the employer’s stated reason was not honestly held and instead concealed discrimination.
Smith v. Citizens Telecom Services Company LLC — Seventh Circuit Settlement Ruling
Date: August 26, 2026
Case No.: 25-3137
Summary:
The Seventh Circuit affirmed enforcement of a $102,000 settlement between an employee and her former employer in a lawsuit alleging discrimination, harassment, and retaliation under Title VII.
After an unsuccessful settlement conference, the employee’s attorney continued negotiations and sent a $102,000 settlement offer, which Citizens Telecom accepted. The employee later argued that she had not authorized her attorney to settle the case.
Applying Indiana agency law, the Seventh Circuit concluded that the attorney had apparent authority to negotiate and settle because the employee had previously placed the attorney in the position of acting as her sole negotiator. The employer therefore reasonably believed that the attorney had authority when it accepted the settlement offer. The employee’s later statement that she had not agreed to settle did not undo an agreement that had already been formed.
Implications:
Although the decision was nonprecedential, it offers a practical reminder for employees and employers participating in Indiana employment litigation. Communications between clients and their attorneys about settlement authority should be clear, and parties negotiating with counsel may in some circumstances rely on the apparent authority created by the client’s own conduct.
Rachwalski v. Blanche — Seventh Circuit Title VII Ruling
Date: August 28, 2026
Case No.: 25-2848
Summary:
The Seventh Circuit affirmed summary judgment against a former FBI agent who alleged sex discrimination under Title VII after being given the choice to resign or be terminated near the end of her probationary period.
The FBI cited multiple performance concerns in support of the proposed termination. The court found insufficient evidence that the decision was made because of the employee’s sex. It also rejected her hostile-work-environment claim as untimely.
Because the plaintiff was a federal employee, federal regulations required her to initiate contact with an Equal Employment Opportunity counselor within 45 days of the alleged discriminatory action. The conduct she relied on for her sex-based hostile-work-environment claim occurred outside that period, and she did not identify a related discriminatory act within the filing window that would make the earlier conduct timely.
Implications:
The decision emphasizes both evidentiary requirements and procedural deadlines in employment discrimination cases. Employees must act quickly when administrative deadlines apply, while employers should maintain consistent and well-supported documentation of performance concerns and employment decisions.
Conclusion: Looking Back on Indiana’s Labor Law Updates from August 2026
As Indiana courts continue to shape employee protections around discrimination, FMLA, wrongful termination, separation agreements, wage disputes, ADA accommodations, non-competes, and hostile work environments, having local counsel matters. At HKM Employment Attorneys in Indianapolis, our fearless litigators—including Katie Bensberg, Natalie Dickey, and Benjamin Ellis—focus solely on representing employees in claims ranging from contract breaches and unpaid wages to whistleblower retaliation and employer investigations. With responsive client care and deep familiarity with both local and federal labor law, we stand ready to guide you. If recent case outcomes reflect your experience, contact our Indianapolis office to see how we can help protect your rights in state or federal court.