September 2026 Labor Law Updates for Milwaukee, Wisconsin
September 2026 brought several important developments in Wisconsin labor and employment law, including federal court decisions addressing disability accommodations, workplace discrimination, retaliation, and employee safety complaints. This monthly roundup from HKM Employment Attorneys highlights significant legal developments affecting Wisconsin employees, employers, HR professionals, and compliance leaders.
At-a-Glance Overview
Key Wisconsin employment law developments in September 2026 included:
-
Federal court rulings clarifying employers’ obligations to accommodate workers with disabilities, including ADHD and physical impairments.
-
Decisions addressing sex discrimination in public employment and the legal standards for hostile work environment and retaliation claims.
-
A federal appellate ruling examining whether on-call responsibilities constitute essential job functions under disability discrimination law.
-
Two EEOC settlements involving religious discrimination and workplace accommodation requests.
-
Wisconsin enforcement action recovering wages for 23 minors following child labor violations.
-
An appellate decision addressing unemployment benefit fraud and repayment obligations.
If you have experienced discrimination, retaliation, wrongful termination, or another workplace rights violation in Wisconsin, HKM Employment Attorneys can help you understand your legal options. Contact HKM Employment Attorneys to discuss your circumstances with an experienced employment attorney.
Reher v. Village of Palmyra — Sex Discrimination and Public Employment
Date: September 4, 2026
Case Number: 26-cv-320 (W.D. Wis.)
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin allowed a sex discrimination claim brought by Samantha Reher, a part-time emergency medical technician (EMT), to proceed against the Village of Palmyra and Police Chief Scott Pavlock.
Reher alleged that she was denied a full-time EMT position because of her sex. Her lawsuit included claims under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act and the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
The defendants sought dismissal of her constitutional claim, arguing that she had not adequately established municipal liability and that the police chief was entitled to qualified immunity.
The court rejected those arguments at the pleading stage, finding that Reher had sufficiently alleged sex-based discrimination and a basis for municipal liability. The court also determined that the police chief was not entitled to dismissal based on qualified immunity at this stage.
Implications:
The ruling reinforces the constitutional protections available to Wisconsin public employees who experience discrimination in hiring or promotion decisions.
Municipal employers must ensure that recruitment and promotion processes use consistent, nondiscriminatory criteria. Employees alleging sex discrimination by government employers may have claims under both federal employment discrimination statutes and constitutional law.
The ruling did not establish that discrimination occurred; it allowed Reher’s constitutional claim to proceed.
Chic v. Waterford Union High School District — Disability Accommodation and the Interactive Process
Date: September 11, 2026
Case Number: 25-cv-991 (E.D. Wis.)
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin declined to grant summary judgment to either party in a disability discrimination lawsuit involving Thomas Chic, a former school district custodian.
Chic, who experienced foot drop, alleged that Waterford Union High School District failed to accommodate his disability and unlawfully terminated his employment.
The dispute centered on whether Chic could perform the essential duties of his custodial position with reasonable accommodations and whether the district adequately considered his medical restrictions.
The court identified genuine factual disputes about Chic’s ability to perform his job and the district’s handling of his accommodation needs. In particular, the record raised questions about whether the employer interpreted his physician’s restrictions too broadly and failed to engage in an adequate interactive process to identify potential accommodations.
Because those disputes could not be resolved through summary judgment, the case was permitted to continue.
Implications:
This decision highlights the importance of individualized evaluations when Wisconsin employees request workplace accommodations.
Employers should avoid automatically concluding that medical restrictions make an employee incapable of performing a position. Instead, they should evaluate essential job duties, communicate with the employee, and consider reasonable adjustments before taking adverse employment action.
Employees with physical disabilities may have viable discrimination claims when an employer fails to meaningfully explore reasonable accommodations.
Friedman v. Mid-West Family Services LLP — ADHD Accommodations and Disability Retaliation
Date: September 11, 2026
Case Number: 26-cv-263 (W.D. Wis.)
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin denied an employer’s motion to dismiss a lawsuit alleging disability discrimination, failure to accommodate, and retaliation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
Joel Friedman, a sales development representative at Mid-West Family Services, alleged that his employer failed to accommodate his attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
Friedman had requested a quieter workspace because noise and workplace interruptions made concentrating difficult. He also requested more consistent internal communication practices to help manage the effects of his disability.
According to the complaint, his supervisor denied or ignored those requests. Friedman was subsequently placed on a performance improvement plan and terminated.
The employer argued that Friedman had not adequately communicated his accommodation needs and that his retaliation claim was procedurally barred.
The court disagreed, finding that Friedman’s allegations plausibly established that the employer understood his requests were related to his disability. The court also concluded that the employer had not demonstrated that Friedman failed to exhaust the administrative procedures required for his retaliation claim.
Implications:
The decision is particularly relevant to Wisconsin employees with ADHD, attention-related limitations, and other conditions that may affect concentration or workplace productivity.
An employee does not necessarily have to use formal legal terminology when requesting a reasonable accommodation. When an employer understands that a worker is requesting a workplace adjustment because of a disability, ADA obligations may be triggered.
Employers should consider accommodations such as reduced distractions, workspace modifications, and changes to communication practices when appropriate. They should also carefully evaluate disability-related requests before imposing discipline for performance concerns.
The court’s decision allows the lawsuit to continue but does not determine whether the employer violated the ADA.
Knox v. Wisconsin Department of Transportation — Essential Job Functions and Disability Accommodations
Date: September 23, 2026
Case Number: 25-3211 (7th Cir.)
Summary:
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit affirmed a ruling in favor of the Wisconsin Department of Transportation in a disability discrimination lawsuit brought by former communications specialist Alexia Knox.
Knox alleged that the department violated the Rehabilitation Act by failing to accommodate her disability and terminating her employment.
A central issue was whether being available for on-call assignments outside normal business hours was an essential function of her position.
Knox argued that she could perform her duties if permitted to work exclusively during regular business hours.
The appellate court concluded that on-call availability was essential to the communications specialist position, particularly because the department needed employees to respond to severe weather events and major traffic incidents occurring outside normal business hours.
The court also found that the requested accommodation would require other employees to assume Knox’s on-call responsibilities. Under the circumstances, the employer was not required to redistribute those essential duties.
The court therefore affirmed summary judgment for the department.
Implications:
This decision illustrates an important limitation on reasonable accommodation obligations under federal disability law.
Although employers must consider accommodations for qualified employees with disabilities, they generally are not required to eliminate essential job functions or redistribute those duties to other employees.
Wisconsin employers should ensure that job descriptions accurately identify essential responsibilities, including irregular schedules or emergency availability when genuinely necessary.
Employees should understand that the reasonableness of a requested accommodation depends partly on whether it would allow them to perform the essential functions of their positions.
Ginger v. Froedtert Health Inc. — Hostile Work Environment and Retaliation
Date: September 28, 2026
Case Number: 25-cv-194 (E.D. Wis.)
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin granted summary judgment to Froedtert Health in a lawsuit alleging sexual harassment, hostile work environment, and retaliation.
The plaintiff, a healthcare administrative supervisor, alleged that a male coworker subjected her to unwanted physical contact and inappropriate workplace behavior.
She also alleged that her employment ended in retaliation for reporting the conduct.
The court determined that the alleged incidents, considered together, did not meet the legal threshold for a hostile work environment under Title VII. Although the court acknowledged that the conduct could be inappropriate and unprofessional, it concluded that the evidence did not establish harassment sufficiently severe or pervasive to alter the conditions of employment.
The court also rejected the retaliation claim, finding insufficient evidence connecting the plaintiff’s harassment complaint to her separation from employment.
The employer had presented evidence of performance concerns and conduct during a performance improvement meeting that supported its employment decision.
Implications:
The decision illustrates the distinction between inappropriate workplace behavior and conduct that meets the legal requirements for a federal hostile work environment claim.
Wisconsin employees pursuing harassment claims must generally demonstrate that the conduct was sufficiently severe or pervasive to create an abusive working environment.
For retaliation claims, employees must also establish a connection between protected activity, such as reporting unlawful harassment, and a materially adverse employment action.
Employers should nevertheless investigate workplace harassment complaints promptly. Conduct that does not ultimately satisfy the legal standard for a hostile work environment may still violate workplace policies or warrant corrective action.
Brown v. Labor and Industry Review Commission — Unemployment Benefits and Fraud Penalties
Date: September 22, 2026
Case Number: 2024AP2299 (Wis. Ct. App.)
Summary:
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals upheld a determination by the Labor and Industry Review Commission (LIRC) that two self-employed individuals improperly received Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA) benefits.
Todd and Sonja Brown operated an online business selling beer and liquor memorabilia. During the COVID-19 pandemic, they received 74 weeks of unemployment assistance after reporting that their business had closed and that they were not working or receiving self-employment income.
The Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development subsequently determined that the Browns had continued operating their business and making sales while receiving benefits.
LIRC concluded that the Browns knowingly provided false information on their benefit applications and weekly certifications.
The Court of Appeals affirmed the determination, allowing the state to recover improperly paid benefits and impose applicable fraud penalties.
Implications:
The decision reinforces Wisconsin’s authority to investigate unemployment benefit fraud and recover payments obtained through intentional misrepresentations.
Workers and self-employed individuals receiving unemployment benefits must accurately disclose work activities and income.
The ruling also illustrates the substantial financial consequences that may follow a finding of unemployment insurance fraud, including repayment obligations and monetary penalties.
Stotesbery v. Dousman Transport Company — Workplace Safety and Retaliation Protections
Date: September 30, 2026
Case Number: 25-cv-759 (W.D. Wis.)
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin dismissed a retaliation lawsuit brought by former school bus driver David Stotesbery against Dousman Transport Company.
Stotesbery alleged that his employer retaliated against him after he refused to operate a school bus because of concerns about its rear emergency exit door.
He pursued his claim under the federal Surface Transportation Assistance Act (STAA), which protects certain transportation employees who report safety violations or refuse to operate vehicles under legally protected circumstances.
The court recognized that Stotesbery had alleged protected activity by reporting safety concerns and refusing to operate a vehicle he believed was unsafe.
However, the court concluded that his amended complaint did not adequately establish that the employer subjected him to an adverse employment action because of that activity.
The court emphasized that Stotesbery had been given the option of remaining at the terminal while a supervisor operated the bus. His allegations did not establish that this alternative constituted unlawful discipline or forced resignation.
The court dismissed the amended complaint and closed the case.
Implications:
The decision demonstrates that workers pursuing retaliation claims must establish more than protected activity. They must also identify an adverse employment action and a legally sufficient connection between that action and their protected conduct.
Wisconsin transportation workers have important protections when reporting vehicle safety concerns, but the circumstances surrounding an alleged retaliation or constructive discharge remain critical.
Employers should avoid punishing workers for good-faith safety complaints and should document how they respond to reported hazards.
Marquardt v. McDonough — Age and Disability Discrimination in Federal Employment
Date: September 30, 2026
Case Number: 21-cv-393 (W.D. Wis.)
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin granted summary judgment to the Department of Veterans Affairs in a lawsuit involving allegations of age and disability discrimination.
Nancy Marquardt, a registered nurse formerly employed at the Clement J. Zablocki VA Medical Center, alleged that she experienced discrimination and a hostile work environment because of her age and disabilities, including a history of cancer and knee injuries.
She brought claims under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) and the Rehabilitation Act.
The court determined that Marquardt had not presented sufficient evidence connecting the alleged workplace mistreatment to her age.
The court also concluded that her disability discrimination allegations were either procedurally deficient or unsupported by sufficient evidence to establish liability under the Rehabilitation Act.
In particular, the court found that the record did not support a conclusion that Marquardt’s disability was the sole reason for the challenged employment action.
The court granted the employer’s motion for summary judgment and dismissed the lawsuit.
Implications:
The decision highlights the evidentiary and procedural requirements that employees must satisfy when pursuing federal employment discrimination claims.
Workers alleging age or disability discrimination must connect the challenged employment decisions to protected characteristics through legally sufficient evidence.
Federal employees must also comply with applicable administrative complaint procedures before pursuing certain claims in court.
Wisconsin employers can reduce discrimination risks by maintaining clear performance standards, documenting employment decisions, and consistently applying workplace policies.
EEOC Reaches Religious Accommodation Settlement with Generac — Federal Agency Enforcement
Date: September 30, 2026
Summary:
The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission announced an agreement resolving a religious accommodation charge involving Wisconsin-based generator manufacturer Generac Power Systems.
The case involved an employee who requested permission to use sex-based pronouns consistent with his sincerely held religious beliefs when referring to another employee who identified as transgender.
According to the EEOC, Generac failed to fully engage in the reasonable accommodation process before denying the request. The agency concluded that the company’s handling of the matter violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.
The EEOC also reported that the company’s failure to adequately address the accommodation request contributed to the employee’s resignation.
Generac agreed to resolve the matter through monetary and nonmonetary relief, including changes to its religious accommodation policies and additional employee training.
The publicly announced agreement did not specify the monetary amount.
Implications:
The settlement highlights the legal complexities Wisconsin employers may face when religious accommodation requests intersect with other workplace discrimination and harassment concerns.
Title VII requires covered employers to reasonably accommodate sincerely held religious beliefs unless doing so would impose an undue hardship under the applicable legal standard.
Employers should evaluate requests individually, communicate with employees about possible accommodations, and carefully consider the rights of everyone affected.
The settlement also emphasizes the importance of maintaining clear procedures for handling religious accommodation requests rather than rejecting them without meaningful consideration.
EEOC Settles Religious Discrimination Lawsuit Against The Rock Snowpark — Religious Expression and Termination
Date: September 28, 2026
Case Number: 25-cv-940 (E.D. Wis.)
Summary:
The EEOC announced a $20,000 settlement with Crystal Ridge Ski Area, doing business as The Rock Snowpark, a recreational facility in Franklin, Wisconsin.
The federal lawsuit alleged that the employer fired a Christian lift operations manager because of religious material he posted on his personal social media accounts.
According to the EEOC, the employee’s posts were not directed at the employer or its employees, and the company had not received complaints from customers, vendors, or employees about the material.
Nevertheless, a supervisor reportedly objected to the posts. After receiving a warning, the employee posted another Bible verse and was subsequently terminated.
The EEOC alleged that the termination constituted religious discrimination under Title VII.
Under the settlement, The Rock Snowpark agreed to pay $20,000 and comply with additional requirements, including employee training, policy changes, reporting of religious discrimination complaints, and two years of EEOC monitoring.
Implications:
The settlement underscores the protections available to Wisconsin employees against adverse employment actions based on their religious beliefs.
Employers should carefully distinguish between an employee’s personal religious expression and conduct that may lawfully warrant workplace discipline.
Employment decisions based on an employer’s disagreement with an employee’s religious beliefs can create significant legal risks.
The case also demonstrates that employees’ off-duty social media activity may raise employment discrimination issues when an employer’s response is motivated by a protected characteristic.
Wisconsin Recovers $17,000 for Minor Workers Following Child Labor Violations — State Enforcement Action
Date: September 29, 2026
Summary:
The Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development and Department of Justice announced the recovery of approximately $17,000 in penalty wages owed to 23 minor workers following an investigation into child labor violations.
The investigation involved Iron Arch, a McDonald’s franchise operator in Wisconsin.
According to state officials, the employer violated Wisconsin laws regulating the employment of minors by allowing underage workers to work outside legally permitted hours, exceed maximum daily working hours, and work shifts of six or more hours without required 30-minute breaks.
The violations were identified through a Department of Workforce Development investigation stemming from an employee complaint.
After the employer failed to repay the wages identified by the department, the matter was referred to the Wisconsin Department of Justice.
State officials obtained a judgment and recovered funds through a coordinated enforcement effort involving the Department of Revenue.
In addition to the $17,000 recovered for affected workers, the employer was ordered to pay $59,754 in civil forfeitures and surcharges.
Implications:
The enforcement action demonstrates Wisconsin’s continued attention to child labor protections and its willingness to pursue employers that violate restrictions on the employment of minors.
Businesses employing workers under age 18 must comply with applicable rules governing work schedules, daily and weekly hour limits, and required meal breaks.
Employers in retail, food service, hospitality, and other industries that frequently employ teenagers should review their scheduling and timekeeping procedures to ensure compliance.
The case also illustrates that employees can report suspected child labor violations and that state agencies may coordinate enforcement efforts to recover compensation owed to affected workers.
Conclusion: Looking Back on Wisconsin’s Labor Law Updates from September 2026
Wisconsin employees may face serious workplace challenges involving unpaid wages, discrimination, retaliation, whistleblower claims and wrongful termination. At HKM Employment Attorneys in Milwaukee, our Wisconsin employment lawyers help employees evaluate their options and pursue accountability in matters involving wage and overtime claims, whistleblower claims, and wrongful termination. Our team’s depth of experience and commitment ensure you’re not navigating this alone. When court decisions resonate with your experience, contact our Milwaukee office to learn how we can help protect your rights and pursue justice in your case.