Summary of August 2026 Labor Law Updates for Boise, Idaho
August brought several noteworthy developments affecting Idaho labor law and workplace rights, including federal decisions involving disability discrimination, sex discrimination, wage claims, and employment contracts. This August 2026 employment update from HKM Employment Attorneys also covers a National Labor Relations Board proceeding involving Idaho workers.
August 2026 produced several important Idaho workplace developments involving disability discrimination, discrimination evidence, wage and contract claims, and collective bargaining rights. Employees or employers with questions about Idaho workplace rights or employment disputes can contact HKM Employment Attorneys for guidance about their specific circumstances.
Mills v. Union Pacific Railroad Co. — Federal Court Ruling
Date: August 17, 2026
Case No.: 1:22-cv-00143-DCN
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the District of Idaho declined to overturn a jury verdict finding that Union Pacific Railroad violated the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) when it terminated employee Monte Mills. Union Pacific argued after trial that it was entitled to judgment as a matter of law, including on the grounds that Mills was not qualified for his position and posed a direct threat.
The court rejected those arguments. It concluded that sufficient evidence supported the jury’s determination that Mills was a qualified individual under the ADA and that Union Pacific had not established its direct-threat defense. Among other things, the court determined that the jury could reasonably conclude the medical and testing evidence relied upon by the railroad did not establish an imminent or likely safety threat. The court therefore denied Union Pacific’s renewed motion for judgment as a matter of law.
Implications:
The ruling illustrates the importance of an individualized, evidence-based assessment when an Idaho employer relies on safety concerns to take action against an employee with a disability. Employers invoking the ADA’s direct-threat defense should be prepared to demonstrate that their conclusions are supported by objective evidence rather than assumptions about an employee’s medical condition.
Peck v. United Parcel Service, Inc. — Ninth Circuit Employment Discrimination and Wage Ruling
Date: August 19, 2026
Case No.: 25-215
Summary:
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed summary judgment for UPS in a lawsuit brought by former manager Heidi Peck after she was terminated following two internal investigations into misreported service failures. Peck alleged sex discrimination under Title VII, breach of contract and the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, a violation of the Idaho Wage Claim Act involving an unpaid year-end performance bonus, and breach of contract involving UPS’s employee dispute-resolution procedures.
The Ninth Circuit held that Peck had not produced sufficient evidence that UPS’s stated reason for terminating her was a pretext for sex discrimination. Although she identified male employees who were not terminated following investigations, the court concluded that they were not similarly situated in all material respects because each had been implicated in only one investigation, while Peck had been involved in two separate investigations. The court also affirmed dismissal of her bonus-related claims.
On Peck’s contract claim, the court emphasized language in UPS’s dispute-resolution manual stating that the program did not create an express or implied employment contract or alter the company’s at-will employment policy. The court held that this language prevented the manual from becoming part of Peck’s employment contract.
Implications:
For Idaho employees pursuing discrimination claims based on allegedly more favorable treatment of coworkers, the decision highlights the importance of showing that proposed comparators were similarly situated in meaningful respects. For employers, it also illustrates how clear disclaimers in employee handbooks and dispute-resolution policies can help preserve at-will employment and reduce the likelihood that internal policies will be treated as contractual obligations.
Gonzales v. Battelle Energy Alliance, LLC — ADA Attorneys’ Fees Order
Date: August 19, 2026
Case No.: 4:20-cv-00102-BLW
Summary:
The U.S. District Court for the District of Idaho issued another order in the long-running ADA litigation between Roman Gonzales and Idaho Falls-based Battelle Energy Alliance. Earlier proceedings resulted in a jury verdict for Gonzales on disability discrimination and retaliation claims arising from Battelle’s decision to revoke his fitness-for-duty certification and terminate his employment based on his use of prescribed pain medication. The Ninth Circuit upheld the relevant judgment in April 2026.
In its August order, the district court awarded Gonzales an additional $39,412.75 in attorneys’ fees and $88,491.80 in appellate attorneys’ fees, along with $819.46 in appellate costs. The court also addressed the release of Battelle’s supersedeas bond and required the parties to resolve remaining post-judgment interest.
Implications:
Although the August ruling primarily concerned the financial consequences of the earlier ADA judgment rather than creating a new liability standard, it underscores the substantial costs that can follow an unsuccessful employment-discrimination defense. The underlying litigation is also significant for Idaho employers in safety-sensitive workplaces because the Ninth Circuit previously held that Battelle’s fitness-for-duty determination could be reviewed under the ADA rather than treated as a nonreviewable national-security decision.
Asplundh Tree Expert Employees Vote to Retain IBEW Representation — NLRB Representation Proceeding
Date: August 21, 2026
Case No.: 27-RD-390414
Summary:
The National Labor Relations Board certified the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 291, as the representative of a bargaining unit of employees working from Asplundh Tree Expert’s Fruitland, Idaho facility. The unit includes full-time and regular part-time tree trimmers, trainees, sprayers, ground workers, operators, and certain forepersons performing line-clearance tree trimming across numerous Idaho counties and several counties in Oregon.
The proceeding began with a decertification petition filed in July. In the August 13 election tally, 56 employees voted for continued union representation and 18 voted against it, with 74 ballots counted and three challenged ballots that were not determinative. The NLRB issued its Certification of Representative on August 21.
Implications:
The result preserves union representation for this multistate workforce, including workers operating across a substantial portion of Idaho. For Idaho employers and employees covered by the National Labor Relations Act, the proceeding provides a current example of how employees may use the NLRB election process to determine whether an existing union continues to represent a bargaining unit.
Conclusion: Looking Back on Idaho Labor Law Updates from August 2026
Idaho’s recent rulings on wage-and-hour violations, wrongful termination, non-compete enforcement, and disability accommodations underscore the need for knowledgeable local counsel. At HKM Employment Attorneys in Boise, our team has secured over $250 million for employees since 2003. We handle everything from unpaid wage claims, FMLA and ADA accommodations, to contract review, whistleblower protection, and hostile work environment cases, using an expert approach and fearless advocacy. If recent court decisions in Idaho have impacted you or a loved one, contact our Boise office to explore how we can help safeguard your workplace rights.