Age Discrimination Case: $560,000 in Attorneys’ Fees

How do you turn a run-of-the-mill termination for poor performance into an $800,000 liability?  We find the answer in the Sears Roebuck catalog. 

Former Sears employee Gunnar Steward sued for age discrimination after his termination for performance reasons.  The facts of the case are relatively unremarkable.  In fact, the evidence supporting Steward’s discrimination claim was weak enough that a judge dismissed the case once, before it was reinstated by the Court of Appeals. 

Instead of settling the case, Sears decided to take the case to trial and lost.  The jury awarded Steward $240,985 ($92,985 in back pay and $148,000 in front pay).  Sears then successfully obtained a trial court ruling setting aside the verdict and ordering a new trial.  However, on appeal, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals reinstated the verdict.  Now, after the dust has settled, Sears must pay not only the $240,000 jury award but also $560,000 in attorney’s fees.  Steward’s attorneys were awarded nearly $425,000 for their work in the trial court and an additional $136,000 for the appeal. 

This case demonstrates that employment discrimination cases are risky, not only because of the damages a jury might award (consider the recent sexual orientation case in Washington that resulted in a verdict of $4.4 million), but also because a successful employee will almost always collect attorney’s fees, which can be substantial.  Employers beware! 

An additional article about this case can be found here.  The Third Circuit Court of Appeals opinion discusses the evidence in the case and can be read here.  The trial court’s recent opinion awarding fees can be read here. 

Picture of Daniel Kalish

Daniel Kalish

A graduate of Harvard College and Yale Law School, Mr. Kalish is an experienced trial lawyer who has tried more than thirty trials to jury verdict. Mr. Kalish’s practice focuses on complex trial work, and he represents employees in all aspects of employment litigation.

Learn More...

Related Posts

Military Spouse

You are the spouse of a member of the military. Not only has your spouse sacrificed for his or her country by always being ready to defend it, but you have sacrificed your family life for the country, as well. We thank you and salute you. In addition to our

Read More »

Colorado Leave Donation Programs: Know Your Rights

Many Colorado employers have programs that allow their employees to essentially donate their accrued paid time off (PTO), including sick leave and vacation days, to co-workers who are experiencing health or family emergencies or serious medical issues. Not only do these leave-donation programs promote the ultimate level of goodwill amongst

Read More »