September 2026 Labor Law Updates for Huntsville, Alabama
September 2026 brought several significant developments in Alabama labor and employment law, including federal appellate decisions addressing workplace discrimination, retaliation, employee discipline, and adverse employment actions. This monthly roundup from HKM Employment Attorneys examines the most important court rulings and regulatory announcements affecting Alabama employees, employers, HR professionals, and compliance leaders.
September 2026 saw important developments in Alabama workplace rights, particularly concerning discrimination, retaliation, religious accommodations, employee discipline, and unemployment benefits. These court rulings and agency announcements reinforce the importance of understanding both employee protections and employer compliance obligations under Alabama and federal law.
If you believe your workplace rights have been violated or have questions about how these developments may affect your employment, contact HKM Employment Attorneys. Our employment attorneys can help you understand your legal options and determine appropriate next steps.
Guthrie v. Coal Bed Services, Inc. — Federal Court Ruling on Racial Discrimination and Retaliation
Date: September 1, 2026
Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
Case Number: 24-10572
Summary:
The Eleventh Circuit revived racial discrimination and retaliation claims brought by two Black employees against Alabama-based Coal Bed Services, Inc. and its parent company, Pate Holdings, Inc.
DeMarkus Hall and Eddie Hughes worked as laborer-operators for Coal Bed Services. After complaining about allegedly discriminatory treatment by a supervisor, both employees were terminated following their refusal to participate in a workplace drug test.
A White coworker who refused the same drug test was also initially terminated but was permitted to return to work shortly afterward. The employer also paid the White employee for a full shift, while Hall and Hughes received only partial-shift pay.
Hall and Hughes alleged that the employer’s actions reflected racial discrimination and retaliation for their earlier complaints. Their claims arose under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and 42 U.S.C. § 1981.
Although the federal district court initially dismissed their claims through summary judgment, the Eleventh Circuit reversed that decision.
The appellate court concluded that the employees had presented sufficient circumstantial evidence for a reasonable jury to find intentional discrimination and retaliation. The court emphasized differences in how similarly situated employees were treated, the timing of disciplinary decisions, and other evidence suggesting potentially discriminatory motives.
The case was returned to the district court for further proceedings.
Implications:
This ruling reinforces important protections against racial discrimination and retaliation under federal employment law.
For Alabama employees, the decision demonstrates that discriminatory intent can be established through a combination of circumstantial evidence, even without an explicit admission of racial bias.
Employers should evaluate whether disciplinary policies, drug-testing procedures, reinstatement decisions, and compensation practices are applied consistently across employees. Significant differences in how workers are treated following similar conduct may support discrimination claims.
The ruling also underscores the legal risks employers face when taking adverse action against employees who have recently reported workplace discrimination.
Willingham v. Lyash — Federal Court Ruling on Disability Discrimination and Retaliation
Date: September 9, 2026
Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
Case Number: 25-13672
Summary:
The Eleventh Circuit upheld the dismissal of disability discrimination, race discrimination, hostile work environment, and retaliation claims brought by Eric Willingham against his former employer, the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA).
Willingham alleged that TVA discriminated against him because of his disability and race, failed to accommodate his disability, subjected him to a hostile work environment, and retaliated against him for participating in earlier equal employment opportunity proceedings.
His employment was terminated following disciplinary issues, including an incident in which he was found sleeping at work while subject to a last-chance disciplinary agreement.
The federal district court ruled in TVA’s favor, and the Eleventh Circuit affirmed.
The appellate court determined that Willingham had not properly exhausted the administrative remedies required for his disability discrimination and accommodation claims. His earlier administrative complaint had not adequately presented those allegations.
The court also found insufficient evidence to establish intentional racial discrimination, a legally actionable hostile work environment, or a causal connection between his protected activities and the alleged retaliation.
Regarding retaliation, the court emphasized that Willingham had not shown that the relevant decision-makers knew about his previous discrimination complaints.
Implications:
This decision highlights the importance of properly following administrative procedures when pursuing federal workplace discrimination claims.
Alabama employees who believe they have experienced discrimination or an unlawful denial of reasonable accommodations should carefully document their complaints and ensure that their administrative filings identify the types of discrimination involved.
For employers, the ruling reinforces the importance of consistent disciplinary documentation and legitimate, evidence-supported reasons for employment decisions.
It also illustrates that successful retaliation claims generally require evidence connecting protected employee activity to the employer’s adverse action.
Fennel v. Elmore County Board of Education — Federal Court Ruling on Sex Discrimination and Interracial Association
Date: September 10, 2026
Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
Case Number: 25-13896
Summary:
The Eleventh Circuit affirmed summary judgment in favor of the Elmore County Board of Education in a workplace discrimination lawsuit brought by former assistant principal Amanda Fennel.
Fennel, a White female administrator at Wetumpka High School, was terminated in May 2022 following an investigation into allegations of inappropriate workplace conduct involving another assistant principal, a Black male employee.
The school board concluded that the administrators had engaged in inappropriate behavior during working hours. Both employees were terminated.
Fennel subsequently sued the board under Title VII, alleging sex discrimination and racial discrimination based on her association with a Black coworker.
She argued that the district’s disciplinary practices reflected unequal treatment and that her sex and interracial association were motivating factors in her dismissal.
The district court dismissed her claims, finding insufficient evidence that discrimination influenced the board’s decision.
The Eleventh Circuit affirmed, concluding that the evidence did not establish a genuine factual dispute about whether sex or race-based bias was a motivating factor in Fennel’s termination.
The court explained that a discrimination claim cannot succeed merely because an employer’s decision appears unfair, questionable, or mistaken. The employee must present evidence from which a reasonable jury could conclude that unlawful discrimination influenced the employment decision.
Implications:
This decision provides guidance on the evidentiary requirements for workplace discrimination claims involving multiple alleged motivations.
Under Title VII, employees may pursue discrimination claims when a protected characteristic was a motivating factor in an adverse employment decision, even if other legitimate factors also contributed.
However, employees must still present evidence supporting a reasonable inference of discrimination.
For Alabama schools, public employers, and private businesses, the decision reinforces the importance of conducting thorough workplace investigations and documenting legitimate reasons for disciplinary actions.
Employees who suspect discriminatory treatment should preserve records showing how other workers were treated under comparable circumstances.
Ogles v. City of Birmingham — Federal Court Ruling on Equal Pay Act Claims and Procedural Requirements
Date: September 15, 2026
Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
Case Number: 26-11079
Summary:
The Eleventh Circuit dismissed an appeal involving employment discrimination and unequal pay allegations against the City of Birmingham because an Equal Pay Act claim remained unresolved in the district court.
Greg Ogles filed a lawsuit alleging that the city had unlawfully denied him promotions and subjected him to discriminatory compensation practices.
His amended complaint included claims under several federal civil rights statutes, along with a separate claim under the Equal Pay Act.
During the proceedings, the parties attempted to dismiss the Equal Pay Act claim through a joint stipulation. The district court subsequently granted summary judgment on the other discrimination claims, and Ogles appealed.
However, the Eleventh Circuit determined that the attempted dismissal of the Equal Pay Act claim was procedurally ineffective.
The appellate court explained that Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41 generally governs dismissal of an entire action rather than individual claims within an ongoing lawsuit. Because the district court had not otherwise properly resolved the Equal Pay Act claim, its decision was not a final judgment.
The Eleventh Circuit therefore dismissed the appeal for lack of appellate jurisdiction without deciding the underlying discrimination allegations.
Implications:
This ruling emphasizes the importance of following proper procedures when litigating workplace discrimination and wage-related claims.
For Alabama employees pursuing claims under the Equal Pay Act or other federal employment statutes, procedural mistakes can delay appellate review even when a district court has already ruled on most of the dispute.
Employers and their legal representatives should also ensure that settlement agreements, claim dismissals, and court orders properly resolve the relevant claims.
The decision does not establish a new standard for proving pay discrimination. Instead, it illustrates how unresolved claims can prevent an appellate court from reviewing an employment dispute.
Hall v. Alabama State University — Federal Court Ruling on Sex Discrimination and Paid Suspension
Date: September 16, 2026
Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
Case Number: 23-13573
Summary:
The Eleventh Circuit upheld a jury’s finding that Alabama State University (ASU) unlawfully discriminated against a female athletics coach when it suspended her during a workplace investigation.
Telma Hall served as head coach of ASU’s women’s softball team for more than eight years. In addition to her coaching responsibilities, Hall taught as an adjunct professor and attended classes at the university.
In 2014, ASU suspended Hall following complaints from parents about her treatment of softball players. Although the university continued paying her coaching salary during the suspension, it prohibited her from contacting students, preventing her from continuing her teaching responsibilities or attending classes.
ASU ultimately terminated her employment.
Hall sued the university under Title VII, alleging that both her suspension and termination constituted sex discrimination.
At trial, Hall presented evidence that ASU had treated a male athletics coach differently when comparable allegations involving student safety were raised. While Hall was suspended during the investigation, the male coach had been allowed to continue working.
A jury found that Hall’s sex was a motivating factor in her suspension and awarded damages.
Both parties subsequently appealed different aspects of the case.
The Eleventh Circuit affirmed the district court’s rulings. It concluded that sufficient evidence supported the jury’s finding of sex discrimination in the suspension decision.
Importantly, the appellate court explained that an employer’s decision to continue paying an employee during a suspension does not necessarily prevent the suspension from qualifying as an adverse employment action.
In Hall’s case, the university imposed additional restrictions that prevented her from performing other professional responsibilities and participating in university activities.
The court also upheld the dismissal of Hall’s separate discrimination claim involving her termination.
Implications:
This decision is particularly significant for Alabama public employers, educational institutions, and employees placed on administrative leave.
It demonstrates that an adverse employment action under Title VII does not necessarily involve termination, demotion, or a reduction in pay.
A suspension that significantly changes an employee’s working conditions or interferes with other professional responsibilities may support a discrimination claim, depending on the circumstances.
The decision also highlights the importance of consistently applying investigative and disciplinary procedures to employees of different sexes.
Alabama employers should evaluate the full consequences of suspending employees, including restrictions on job duties, access to workplaces, and participation in professional activities.
Alabama Department of Workforce Introduces New Unemployment Identity Verification Requirements — Agency Announcement
Date: September 17, 2026
Agency: Alabama Department of Workforce
Summary:
The Alabama Department of Workforce announced new identity verification requirements for individuals filing initial unemployment compensation claims.
Beginning September 30, 2026, claimants must use Login.gov as the primary method of verifying their identities when applying for unemployment benefits.
Under the new procedure, applicants must first submit an initial unemployment claim through the Alabama Unemployment Claimant Portal.
After filing, claimants must complete identity verification within 10 calendar days.
The process may require individuals to provide government-issued identification, personal information, and additional verification materials. Some applicants may also be directed to complete verification through a participating U.S. Postal Service location.
The department warned that failing to complete identity verification within the required period could result in delayed or denied benefits.
Claimants who cannot complete the online process may seek additional assistance at an Alabama Career Center under the department’s established procedures.
The department described the initiative as an effort to prevent fraudulent claims, protect claimant information, and strengthen unemployment insurance administration.
Implications:
This procedural change directly affects Alabama workers who lose their jobs and seek unemployment compensation.
Employees filing claims should be aware of the 10-day verification deadline and follow all instructions in the state’s online claimant portal.
Incomplete verification may create additional financial difficulties for individuals already experiencing unemployment.
Employers and HR professionals should also familiarize themselves with the new requirements so they can provide accurate procedural information to departing employees.
The announcement does not change the underlying eligibility standards for unemployment benefits, but it introduces an additional administrative requirement that claimants must complete.
EEOC v. Blue Bell Creameries, LLC — Federal Lawsuit Alleging Religious Discrimination and Retaliation
Date: September 21, 2026
Agency: U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
Case Number: 1:26-cv-01694-GMB
Summary:
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) announced a federal lawsuit against Blue Bell Creameries, alleging religious discrimination and retaliation at the company’s production facility in Sylacauga, Alabama.
According to the EEOC, a longtime body shop technician who practiced Judaism requested a religious accommodation allowing him to maintain his beard in accordance with his beliefs.
The agency alleged that the employee was terminated in March 2025, less than a month after refusing to shave his beard for religious reasons.
Blue Bell reportedly cited a timekeeping violation as the reason for his termination. However, the EEOC alleged that other employees routinely engaged in similar timekeeping practices without facing comparable disciplinary consequences.
The lawsuit also alleges that a supervisor repeatedly questioned the sincerity of the employee’s religious beliefs without a legitimate basis.
The EEOC contends that the employer’s actions violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits religious discrimination and retaliation against employees who exercise their protected workplace rights.
The agency filed the lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Alabama after unsuccessful efforts to resolve the dispute through its administrative process.
The allegations have not yet been established in court.
Implications:
This lawsuit highlights the importance of religious accommodation protections for Alabama employees.
Under Title VII, employers generally must reasonably accommodate employees’ sincerely held religious beliefs and practices unless doing so would impose an undue hardship on the conduct of their business.
Religious accommodations may involve scheduling, dress requirements, grooming policies, or other workplace practices.
Employers should carefully evaluate requests for religious accommodations rather than automatically enforcing workplace policies without considering employees’ religious needs.
The lawsuit also demonstrates the potential legal consequences of allegedly using routine workplace violations as a justification for disciplining employees who have requested protected accommodations.
Alabama employees who believe they have been denied reasonable religious accommodations or retaliated against for requesting them may have grounds to pursue federal discrimination claims.
Alabama Announces Expanded Workplace Vaping Restrictions — Legislation and Regulatory Announcement
Date: September 23, 2026
Agency: Alabama Department of Public Health
Legislation: Senate Bill 9, Act 2026-505
Summary:
The Alabama Department of Public Health announced that the state’s Clean Indoor Air Act would expand to cover electronic nicotine delivery systems beginning October 1, 2026.
The legislation, enacted earlier in 2026 as Act 2026-505, amends Alabama’s existing restrictions on smoking in enclosed public places.
Under the amended law, electronic cigarettes, vaping devices, and other electronic nicotine delivery systems are included within the statutory definition of smoking.
Consequently, vaping will be subject to the same restrictions as traditional tobacco smoking in locations covered by the law.
These locations include many workplaces, government buildings, educational institutions, health care facilities, restaurants, retail establishments, and other enclosed public spaces.
The Department of Public Health encouraged covered employers and organizations to review their existing policies and signage before the October 1 effective date.
The legislation also renames the statute the Vivian Davis Figures and Barbara Drummond Clean Indoor Air Act.
Implications:
The expanded restrictions affect Alabama employers responsible for maintaining workplaces covered by the state’s indoor smoking regulations.
Employers should review employee handbooks, smoking and vaping policies, workplace notices, and applicable signage to ensure compliance.
Businesses should also communicate any necessary policy changes to employees, supervisors, and managers.
For employees, the amended law provides additional protections against exposure to secondhand emissions from electronic nicotine delivery devices in covered workplaces.
Although the legislation was enacted before September, the September 23 announcement served as an important compliance reminder immediately preceding its October 1 implementation.
Conclusion: Looking Back on Alabama Labor Law Updates from September 2026
With Alabama courts recently addressing disputes in wage-and-hour protections, FMLA compliance, wrongful termination, discrimination, contract enforcement, and federal employee rights, local representation is essential. At HKM Employment Attorneys in Huntsville, our team—led by attorneys like Daniel Kalish, Artur Davis, and Chase Estes—has obtained over $250 million for clients, handling cases from employment contracts and separation agreements to hostile work environments, whistleblower claims, federal employee appeals, discrimination (including FCRA credit report issues), and more. We provide attentive, personalized counsel with a no-fear promise. If you’ve been affected by recent rulings in North Alabama or federal labor decisions, reach out to our Huntsville office to explore how we can defend your workplace rights.