Walla Walla County Sheriff Settles Retaliation Claim

A Tri-City Herald article announced a settlement agreement between Walla Walla County Sheriff’s Office and one of its former employees early this year. The Sheriff’s Office was accused of ongoing
discrimination and retaliation against Lucille Poirier. In the settlement, Poirier will receive $235,000, roughly a third of what she sought in her lawsuit, and significantly less than the cost of a trial. As with most settlements, the Sheriff’s Office does not admit to any wrongdoing in relation to the lawsuit.

The Story

According to Poirier, who worked at the county jail for 10 years, she was injured on the job on two occasions. After her first injury, she claims she was investigated for making a fraudulent claim with the Department of Labor and Industry. She was cleared in the investigation, but continued to face increased scrutiny at work. Poirier’s second injury, where she received a concussion, a shoulder injury and was kicked in the ribs, was more severe and she believes led to her eventual termination. As a result of her concussion, she began having more frequent headaches that became severe migraines. Poirier suffered one of these migraines while at work, and briefly laid down to rest until it was more manageable. Unfortunately, the headache returned later in the day, and she had to lay down a second time. Furthermore, a co-worker had to take her to the hospital at the end of her shift, where she received strong painkillers for her migraine. Poirier admits that she probably should have taken a sick day for her migraine, but that she did not do anything that violated jail policy while she was on shift.

Poirier claims she did not exceed her state allowed rest time and that the jail had a full staff during her break periods. She also claims that jail staff members do not have assigned break periods and they take them when they have the chance. However, it was these rest breaks that led to an internal investigation, during which an investigator did not believe Poirier’s statements, and did not feel that she was taking enough responsibility for her actions. Poirier refused to sign the resulting separation agreement and was terminated. Because she was fired, in what has been determined to be retaliation, she was initially denied unemployment benefits until an administrative judge ruled her to be eligible for benefits.

Workplace Injuries & Accommodations

Poirier suffered two work related injuries, filed claims as state and federal allows, and with rehabilitation believed she did not need accommodations for those injuries. Employers are prohibited from discriminating against an individual because of a disability, unless the disability cannot be reasonably accommodated. Such accommodations could include a quiet, low-lit area for brief rests. However, employees needing accommodations are responsible for requesting and making reasonable suggestions for those accommodations. It is then the employers responsibility to determine the feasibility of the accommodations, and further to implement them.

If you feel you have been discriminated against due to a disability in the workplace, an experienced employment law attorney can help.

Picture of Daniel Kalish

Daniel Kalish

A graduate of Harvard College and Yale Law School, Mr. Kalish is an experienced trial lawyer who has tried more than thirty trials to jury verdict. Mr. Kalish’s practice focuses on complex trial work, and he represents employees in all aspects of employment litigation.

Learn More...

Related Posts

San Jose, California’s September 2026 Employment & Labor Law Cases

September 2026 Labor Law Updates for San Jose, California September 2026 brought significant developments in California labor and employment law, including new legislation governing artificial intelligence in the workplace, employee privacy protections, expanded wage enforcement, and important court decisions concerning hiring discrimination. This monthly roundup from HKM Employment Attorneys examines

Read More »

San Francisco, California’s September 2026 Employment & Labor Law Cases

September 2026 Labor Law Updates for San Francisco, California September 2026 brought significant developments in California labor and employment law, including new legislation governing artificial intelligence in the workplace, employee privacy protections, expanded wage enforcement, and important court decisions concerning hiring discrimination. This monthly roundup from HKM Employment Attorneys examines

Read More »

Riverside, California’s September 2026 Employment & Labor Law Cases

Summary of September 2026 Labor Law Updates for Riverside, California September 2026 brought significant developments in California labor and employment law, including new legislation governing artificial intelligence in the workplace, employee privacy protections, expanded wage enforcement, and important court decisions concerning hiring discrimination. This monthly roundup from HKM Employment Attorneys

Read More »